Decide whether you need native analytics or exported data. Ashby is strongest if recruiters need self-serve dashboards inside the ATS, while Greenhouse is a better fit if a BI team needs nightly exports to Amazon S3 or Redshift on Plus or Pro.
Check who will build the reports. Recruiters and hiring managers usually need saved dashboards and simple filters; people analytics teams often need CSV exports, a BI connector, API access or warehouse-ready data.
Watch the plan gates. Ashby AI Report Filters are for Plus and Enterprise customers, Greenhouse BI Connector is on Plus and Pro, Manatal Advanced Report Builder is on Enterprise Plus, and Zoho Recruit’s advanced analytics sit on Enterprise.
Ask for the metrics before the demo. Time-to-hire, time-to-fill, source quality, pass-through rates, offer acceptance, recruiter activity and hiring manager responsiveness should be visible without a spreadsheet rebuild.
Price the add-ons, not just the ATS. Workable’s AI Agent uses credits, Breezy HR lists Breezy Intelligence and SMS as add-ons, and Zoho Recruit has add-ons that can change the real cost.
Do not buy enterprise analytics for a two-role hiring plan. If you only need basic job tracking and source reports, Breezy HR, Workable, Manatal or Zoho Recruit may be a cleaner fit than Greenhouse or Lever.